In short, read the book.
As the first installment in a presumable trilogy, this movie was titled Atlas Shrugged: Part I. A more apt subtitle would have been Take 1. In a clearly rushed production, this adaptation overemphasized visual details such as clothing and decor, and lacked any of the buildup, character development and subtly of the original classic novel. Oh, and there is some really bad CG.
It was clumsily modernized in a way that leaves nothing to the imagination–unlike the book’s more timeless setting which allows the reader to draw the many and sometimes eerie parallels to today’s situation.
Without going into spoiler territory, the plot tipped its hand too soon, both in the lines spoken by the Fedora character and in the parting words at the close. Again, no subtly there. I doubt the movie would be compelling or even decipherable by anyone who hasn’t read the book or is not sympathetic to its philosophy.
When judged by how difficult the task was to adapt this complex book to a modern movie, it might earn a C-. When judged by how enlightening and influential the book was–and the movie should have been–it gets an F. It could have been so much better.
Unless Peter Jackson wants to sign on for Take 2 and spend a couple years on the rest of the story, they shouldn’t make a Part II and III. Like I said, read the book.